Head-to-head
Claude Opus 5 vs GPT-6 Astra: which AI model wins in 2026?
Claude Opus 5 ($25/1M out) and GPT-6 Astra ($50/1M out) are two of the most-used AI models in 2026. Across 4 community votes, Claude Opus 5 leads with 63% approval.
Quick verdict
On Reasoning, Claude Opus 5 and GPT-6 Astra are tied at 5/5. On budget, Claude Opus 5 wins: it starts at $25/1M out versus $50/1M out for GPT-6 Astra.
Line-by-line comparison
Strengths and weaknesses
Claude Opus 5
- Ranked #1 in composite intelligence across 190 models on Artificial Analysis at launch, and 43.3% on Frontier-Bench v0.1 vs 34.4% for GPT-5.6 Sol and 33.7% for Claude Fable 5
- 3.9x better than GPT-5.6 Sol on ARC-AGI-3 novel reasoning (30.2% vs 7.8%), and Elo 1861 on GDPval-AA v2 economic knowledge work, ahead of Fable 5 (1747)
- 79.2% on SWE-bench Pro, within a point of Fable 5 (80.0%) and 10 points above Opus 4.8 (69.2%), at half Fable's price; Cursor's co-founder calls it 'near Fable 5 intelligence at Opus speed and cost'
- Same $5/$25 pricing as Opus 4.8 with a bigger window: 1M context is now the default and only tier, with 128K max output and prompt caching from 512 tokens
- Dual-use safety classifiers trigger 85% less often than on Fable 5, and the new default fallback mode avoids the silent mid-session refusals that plagued Fable's launch
- Self-verifies its work without being told, handles mid-conversation tool changes (beta) without busting the prompt cache, and ships day one on Claude.ai, the API, Bedrock, Vertex and Microsoft Foundry
- Notably slow and very verbose: 52.6 output tokens/s and 68 seconds to first token on Artificial Analysis, and it consumed ~100M output tokens during their eval vs a 63M median
- The verbosity is a real-world cost problem: CodeRabbit measured it reading ~50% more and writing ~65% more than reference frontier models per code-review call
- No actual price cut despite the 'cost-efficient' narrative: identical to Opus 4.8 ($5/$25), nearly GPT-5.6 money ($5/$30), and more than 2x comparable Gemini or Grok tiers
- Reviewers describe a 'brilliant but annoying' personality: over-verification, hedging, and occasional refusals of mundane tasks like resolving a merge conflict (Lenny's Newsletter field review)
- Breaking API change for Opus 4.8 migrants: thinking is on by default and cannot be disabled at xhigh or max effort (returns a 400); Fast mode ($10/$50, ~2.5x faster) is API-only, not on Bedrock or Vertex
GPT-6 Astra
- ARC-AGI 98.5% and GPQA Diamond 96%, highest published scores on novel reasoning benchmarks at launch
- 1.05M context window with 128K max output, larger than Claude or Gemini equivalents
- Full multimodal: text and image input, supports web search, code interpreter, computer use, and MCP tools
- Five-level reasoning effort dial (low to max) lets you trade latency for depth per call
- Available day one on OpenAI API, Azure, and major inference providers
- Structured outputs via JSON schema in response_format for reliable parsing
- $10/$50 pricing is 2x GPT-5.6 Sol ($5/$30) and roughly matches Claude Fable 5.1, not a budget option
- Time to first token P95 of 4.11 seconds, slower than flash-tier models for interactive use
- Output throughput 47.6 chars/s (P5) means long responses take noticeable time
- No open weights: proprietary model with standard OpenAI terms
- Long-context pricing jumps to $20/$75 above 272K tokens, plus 10% for regional data residency
Cast your verdict
One recommendation per tool per gladiator. It reshapes the crowd score everyone sees.
The arena’s verdict on Claude Opus 5
Claude Opus 5 is the sane default of the Series 5 range: most of Fable 5's intelligence (and more than Fable on Frontier-Bench and GDPval) at exactly half the token price, with classifiers that trigger 85% less often. If you migrated workloads to Fable 5 for capability but resent the bill or the false-positive refusals, move them here; if you are still on Opus 4.8, the upgrade is 10 SWE-bench Pro points for free. The two honest reasons to look elsewhere: latency and verbosity. At 52.6 tokens/s with 68s to first token it is a poor fit for interactive UX, and its token appetite quietly inflates real costs beyond the sticker price, so budget-sensitive high-volume pipelines still belong on Sonnet 5, Gemini or DeepSeek. Keep Fable 5 only for the longest autonomous runs where its slight SWE-bench Pro edge compounds.
The arena’s verdict on GPT-6 Astra
GPT-6 Astra is OpenAI current best for the hardest end-to-end work. The ARC-AGI and GPQA scores are genuine frontier marks, and the 1.05M context with 128K output handles enterprise-scale documents. Choose it for complex reasoning, agentic research, and tool-heavy workflows where you need the highest ceiling. The price is premium ($10/$50), latency is moderate, and long-context jobs cost more, so budget-sensitive high-volume pipelines belong on GPT-5.6 Sol or Gemini Flash. If you are already on the Claude stack, Fable 5.1 matches Astra benchmarks at the same price with better cache-read economics.
What the crowd says
On Claude Opus 5
“The sticker price is unchanged but my invoice is not: it writes essays where Opus 4.8 wrote answers. 68 seconds to first token killed it for our support chat, we went back to Sonnet 5.”
“Fed it a 40-tab financial model with cross-sheet formulas and asked for a scenario deck. It got the edge cases the analysts missed. For document-heavy enterprise work this is the best model I have used.”
“We moved off Fable 5 because the bio classifier kept flagging our genomics tooling. Opus 5 does the same work at half the price and I have not seen a single silent reroute since.”
“Migrated our agents from Opus 4.8 the day it dropped. Same bill, and tasks that used to stall at the planning stage now just finish. The 10-point SWE-bench jump is not marketing, our merge queue feels it.”
On GPT-6 Astra
No verdicts yet. Be the first to speak.
Keep comparing
Frequently asked questions
Is Claude Opus 5 better than GPT-6 Astra?
The crowd currently sides with Claude Opus 5: 63% recommend it, versus 50% for GPT-6 Astra (4 votes). The right pick depends on your use case. The line-by-line comparison on this page breaks down pricing, key specs and arena ratings.
Which is cheaper, Claude Opus 5 or GPT-6 Astra?
Claude Opus 5 is cheaper: it starts at $25/1M out, while GPT-6 Astra starts at $50/1M out.
How much do Claude Opus 5 and GPT-6 Astra cost per 1M tokens?
Claude Opus 5: $5/1M in per 1M input tokens, $25/1M out per 1M output tokens. GPT-6 Astra: $10/1M in per 1M input tokens, $50/1M out per 1M output tokens.