Head-to-head

Claude Fable 5 logovsGemini 3 Pro logo

Claude Fable 5 vs Gemini 3 Pro: which AI model wins in 2026?

Claude Fable 5 ($50/1M out) and Gemini 3 Pro ($12/1M out (prompts ≤200K)) are two of the most-used AI models in 2026. Across 7 community votes, Claude Fable 5 leads with 63% approval.

Quick verdict

On Reasoning, pick Claude Fable 5: the arena rates it 5/5 against 4.5/5 for Gemini 3 Pro. On budget, Gemini 3 Pro wins: it starts at $12/1M out (prompts ≤200K) versus $50/1M out for Claude Fable 5.

Line-by-line comparison

From
$50/1M outOfficial Anthropic API list price for claude-fable-5: $10/1M input, $50/1M output, single tier with 1M context by default (no long-context premium), 128K max output; requests refused before any output are not billed. Verified against platform.claude.com (Introducing Claude Fable 5) 2026-07.
$12/1M out (prompts ≤200K)Standard tier: $2/$12 per 1M tokens for prompts ≤200K, $4/$18 above 200K; batch at 50% off. Retired March 9, 2026, successor Gemini 3.1 Pro keeps identical pricing.
Provider
Anthropic
Google (DeepMind)
Context window
1M tokens
1M tokens (64K output)
Input price
$10/1M in
$2/1M in (prompts ≤200K)
Output price
$50/1M out
$12/1M out (prompts ≤200K)
Modalities
text, vision
text, image, audio, video in; text out
Open weights
No
No
Crowd score
63%(4)
57%(3)
Arena ratings (1-5)
Reasoning
5.0
4.5
Coding
5.0
4.5
Writing
4.5
3.5
Speed
2.0
3.5
Value
3.0
4.0

Strengths and weaknesses

Claude Fable 5

  • 80.3% on SWE-bench Pro vs 69.2% for Opus 4.8, 58.6% for GPT-5.5 and 54.2% for Gemini 3.1 Pro, roughly 11 points ahead of the next frontier model
  • 95.0% on SWE-bench Verified (Opus 4.8: 88.6%, GPT-5.5: 82.6%) and 29.3% on Cognition's FrontierCode Diamond split, more than double Opus 4.8's 13.4%
  • Long-horizon autonomy is the real story: Stripe reported a 50-million-line Ruby codebase migration done in one day instead of 2+ months, and Cursor's CEO calls it state of the art on CursorBench
  • Field reports match the benchmarks: HN engineers describe it working 'like an actual engineer' (CRDTs with minimal hand-holding, writing its own fuzzers, one 46x allocation reduction), Simon Willison measured 'several days' worth of work' in a single session
  • 1M token context window by default plus 128K output, and state-of-the-art vision on dense documents (29.8% on GDP.pdf vs 24.9% for GPT-5.5 and 22.5% for Opus 4.8)
  • Refused-before-output requests are not billed, and server-side fallback to Opus 4.8 with fallback credit is built into the API
  • Double the price of Opus 4.8 ($10/$50 vs $5/$25) and slow: single requests on hard tasks routinely run many minutes, Simon Willison bluntly calls it 'slow, expensive'
  • Dual-use safety classifiers misfire on legitimate work: a medical physicist reported fluid dynamics problems and MRI segmentation code refused as biosecurity risks, with requests silently rerouted to Opus 4.8 (the viral HN thread was titled 'If Claude Fable stops helping you, you'll never know'; Anthropic says under 5% of sessions)
  • Rocky launch: US export controls forced Anthropic to suspend access worldwide from June 12 to June 30, 2026, three days after release, with full restoration only on July 1
  • Requires 30-day data retention and is not available under zero data retention, a hard blocker for strict-compliance orgs; also no thinking-off mode, raw chain of thought never returned, assistant prefill returns a 400
  • Not universally state of the art: GPT-5.5 still leads ARC-AGI-2 (85.0% vs 77.1%), and Andon Labs found unblocked Mythos 5 underperformed both Opus 4.7 and GPT-5.5 on Vending-Bench, with reasoning that optimized for detectability rather than actual harm

Gemini 3 Pro

  • Topped LMArena at launch with a record 1501 Elo and scored 91.9% on GPQA Diamond, state of the art at release
  • ARC-AGI-2 at 31.1%, roughly 6x Gemini 2.5 Pro (4.9%) and nearly double GPT-5.1 (17.6%) at the time
  • Best-in-class multimodal understanding: 81% MMMU-Pro, 87.6% Video-MMMU, with a 1M-token context window
  • Strong agentic coding: 76.2% SWE-bench Verified, 54.2% Terminal-Bench 2.0, 1487 Elo on WebDev Arena
  • Undercut rivals on price at $2/$12 per 1M tokens, below Claude Sonnet-class pricing ($3/$15)
  • Configurable thinking_level (low/medium/high) lets developers trade reasoning depth against latency and cost
  • Overconfident hallucinations: on AA-Omniscience it gave a wrong answer 88% of the time instead of declining, vs 48% for Claude Sonnet 4.5 (the-decoder)
  • Sycophancy widely reported by reviewers (Zvi Mowshowitz: 'vast intelligence with no spine'); needs tight system prompts
  • Tool-calling reliability issues in agent stacks: devs reported tool outputs dumped into the chat thread and more scaffolding needed than OpenAI/Anthropic models
  • Slow at high thinking level: time to first token measured around 30-60s on AI Studio despite ~130 tok/s output speed
  • Retired: shut down on the Gemini API and AI Studio on March 9, 2026, with gemini-3-pro-preview now aliased to Gemini 3.1 Pro

Cast your verdict

One recommendation per tool per gladiator. It reshapes the crowd score everyone sees.

Claude Fable 5$50/1M out
63%crowd score · 4
Gemini 3 Pro$12/1M out (prompts ≤200K)
57%crowd score · 3

The arena’s verdict on Claude Fable 5

Take Claude Fable 5 if your workload is genuinely long-horizon: overnight agentic runs, monster migrations, tasks where one multi-hour session replaces days of supervised work. There, the 2x premium over Opus 4.8 pays for itself in task compression, and the benchmarks (80.3% SWE-bench Pro, 11 points clear of the field) are backed by real deployments at Stripe and Cursor. For interactive coding and everyday work, stay on Opus 4.8: 88.6% on SWE-bench Verified at half the price, no classifier misfires, faster turns. Cost-sensitive teams get near-Opus coding from Sonnet 5 at $3/$15 (intro $2/$10 through August 2026). Avoid Fable 5 entirely if your org requires zero data retention or if you work anywhere near biology, medical imaging or security tooling, where the dual-use classifiers still produce false positives and silently swap in Opus 4.8 mid-session.

The arena’s verdict on Gemini 3 Pro

A landmark release that put Google back on top in late 2025, with a huge reasoning jump over Gemini 2.5 Pro and the best multimodal scores of its generation. As of mid-2026 there is no reason to choose it: Google shut it down on the API on March 9, 2026, and Gemini 3.1 Pro costs exactly the same while more than doubling ARC-AGI-2 performance (77.1% vs 31.1%). Teams on legacy deployments should migrate to 3.1 Pro, which the old model ID now points to anyway. Avoid it for hallucination-sensitive workloads unless you add grounding, a weakness reviewers flagged repeatedly.

What the crowd says

On Claude Fable 5

Thumbs Downicus

“I do medical imaging research and the bio classifier keeps flagging my MRI segmentation prompts, then it silently falls back to Opus 4.8 mid-session. At $50 per million output tokens I expect to at least know which model actually answered me.”

Glorius Maximus

“Yes it's 2x the price of Opus and yes the turns are slow. But one overnight Fable run replaced what used to be a week of supervising shorter runs. On a per-task basis it's actually the cheapest model we use.”

Golden Thumbicus

“The 1M context is real, not marketing. I fed it our entire service mesh config plus six months of incident postmortems and it traced a flaky timeout to a retry policy nobody remembered writing. Opus 4.8 never connected those dots.”

Saint Deployus

“Gave it a monorepo migration that Opus 4.8 kept stalling on. It ran for about 40 minutes, came back with the whole thing done plus a test harness it wrote for itself. Felt like reviewing a senior engineer's PR, not babysitting a chatbot.”

On Gemini 3 Pro

Judge Dreadful

“Confidently wrong is its worst mode. On AA-Omniscience it gave a wrong answer 88% of the time instead of declining. Add the sycophancy and you need a tight system prompt to trust it.”

Champion of Vibes

“ARC-AGI-2 at 31% was about 6x Gemini 2.5 Pro and nearly double GPT-5.1 at the time. For visual-heavy work (81 MMMU-Pro) nothing else came close.”

Glorius Maximus

“1501 Elo on LMArena at launch was deserved. Multimodal is where it kills, I feed it lecture videos and dense PDFs and it just gets it. 1M context helps.”

Frequently asked questions

Is Claude Fable 5 better than Gemini 3 Pro?

The crowd currently sides with Claude Fable 5: 63% recommend it, versus 57% for Gemini 3 Pro (7 votes). On Reasoning, Claude Fable 5 rates higher (5/5 vs 4.5/5). The right pick depends on your use case. The line-by-line comparison on this page breaks down pricing, key specs and arena ratings.

Which is cheaper, Claude Fable 5 or Gemini 3 Pro?

Gemini 3 Pro is cheaper: it starts at $12/1M out (prompts ≤200K), while Claude Fable 5 starts at $50/1M out.

How much do Claude Fable 5 and Gemini 3 Pro cost per 1M tokens?

Claude Fable 5: $10/1M in per 1M input tokens, $50/1M out per 1M output tokens. Gemini 3 Pro: $2/1M in (prompts ≤200K) per 1M input tokens, $12/1M out (prompts ≤200K) per 1M output tokens.